Procure-to-Pay, PO Workflows & Spend Governance3 min readUpdated September 2026

Airbase vs Procurify for Commercial Capital and Debt Advisory Firms

For a commercial mortgage or debt advisory firm, the key requirement in either Airbase or Procurify is separating recoverable transaction costs from firm overhead by tagging every third-party order to a deal. Appraisals, reports and legal fees are recovered only if the deal survives, which is when untagged costs surface.

Vendors Covered in this Article

Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.

How do you avoid ordering third-party reports without a deal ID?

An appraisal, environmental report, or property condition assessment ordered without being tagged to a specific transaction from the start becomes a guessing game later when you're trying to bill the borrower or reconcile what's recoverable. Require a deal identifier on every third-party order at the point it's placed, whichever platform you use, so recovery at closing doesn't depend on someone remembering which deal a report belonged to months after it was ordered.

Does the borrower always pay for the ordered report?

Borrowers sometimes cover third-party costs directly, and other times the firm fronts them and bills at closing, or absorbs them if the deal dies. If your platform doesn't distinguish between these payment paths at the point of order, you'll end up manually sorting invoices by payment responsibility every month instead of pulling a clean report. Set this up as a required field on every third-party purchase from day one, and revisit the default for each lender relationship periodically, since some lenders change their preferred payment path as their own underwriting policies shift.

Pitfall: treating a dead deal's costs as a write-off without tracking why

When a deal falls apart, the third-party costs the firm fronted become a real loss, and it's worth knowing not just the total but the pattern, which deal types, borrower profiles, or lenders are associated with the highest fallout rate relative to fees earned. Neither tool calculates this automatically, but if every order is tagged to a deal with its outcome recorded, pulling that analysis is straightforward rather than a research project someone has to reconstruct from memory and old email threads months after the fact.

Pitfall: letting legal fees blend into general professional services

Legal fees on a specific transaction, loan document review, title work, closing counsel, are recoverable costs tied to that deal, not general firm legal expense. Keep them in a distinct category from your own corporate legal spend, retainer agreements, employment matters, and so on, so a deal-level cost report doesn't accidentally include overhead that genuinely has nothing to do with that particular transaction at all.

Pitfall: picking a tool before agreeing on your recovery policy

Before evaluating Airbase or Procurify, get internal agreement on your actual recovery policy: which costs get billed to the borrower directly, which get fronted and reconciled at closing, and what happens on a dead deal. A well-configured tool built on an unclear or inconsistent policy just produces confident-looking numbers that don't actually reflect how your firm handles cost recovery in practice.

Settle these points in your recovery policy before configuring either tool:

  • Decide which costs are billed to the borrower directly, which are fronted and reconciled at closing, and what happens on a dead deal.
  • Require a deal identifier on every third-party order at the moment it is placed.
  • Add a required field showing the payment path: borrower-direct, firm-fronted or absorbed if the deal fails.
  • Keep deal-specific legal fees, such as loan document review and title work, apart from the firm's own corporate legal spend.
  • Record each report's order date and expected expiration alongside the deal record, and track rush fees as their own line.

Pitfall: losing track of report expiration windows

Appraisals and environmental reports typically carry a validity window before a lender or investor considers them stale, and a deal that drags past that window may need a costly update or a fresh report entirely. Track the order date and the expected expiration alongside the deal record, whichever platform you use, so a stalled deal surfaces a report-expiration risk before it becomes an unplanned second bill on a transaction that's already taking longer than expected.

Pitfall: not distinguishing repeat vendors by deal type

An appraiser or environmental firm that's reliable and fast on a straightforward industrial property may be the wrong choice for a specialized asset class where a mistake or a slow turnaround delays the whole deal. Track vendor performance by deal type, not just overall satisfaction, so the next similar transaction routes to a vendor with a track record on that specific property type rather than defaulting to whoever's fastest to respond.

Pitfall: forgetting that a rush order usually costs more

A deal that's moving on a compressed timeline often means paying a rush fee for an expedited appraisal or a faster environmental turnaround, and that premium should be tracked as its own line rather than blended into the base cost of the report. Over time, this tells you something useful: which deal types or clients consistently generate rush fees, which is worth factoring into how you price advisory fees on similarly time-pressured transactions going forward, rather than absorbing that added cost quietly deal after deal without anyone noticing the pattern.

Executive Capability Standard

What Good Looks Like

Good procurement for a commercial debt advisory firm means every third-party cost is tagged to its deal and payment path at the point of order, so recovery at closing and losses on dead deals are both visible without manual reconstruction.

Building The Capability (5-Stage Skill Ladder)

1. Learn:Get internal agreement on your firm's actual recovery policy, which costs bill to the borrower, which get fronted, what happens on a dead deal, before evaluating any tool.
2. Do Manually:Require a deal ID and payment-path field on every third-party purchase request, checked before the order is submitted.
3. Delegate:Assign a deal coordinator or closing manager to own recoverable cost tracking per transaction, separate from general firm AP.
4. Automate:Build required deal and payment-path fields into your purchasing workflow so recovery and fallout reporting don't depend on manual tagging after the fact.
5. Buy:Have Frank, MeetMyCFO's AI CFO, review fallout patterns across dead deals to flag where underwriting or deal selection could reduce absorbed third-party costs.

How to Get Started

Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do we make sure third-party costs get recovered at closing?

Require a deal identifier on every third-party order, appraisal, environmental report, legal fee, at the point it's placed, and track which payment path applies, borrower-direct, firm-fronted, or absorbed on a dead deal. Without that tagging at the source, recovery becomes a manual reconciliation project at closing.

Should legal fees on a specific deal be tracked separately from general firm legal expense?

Yes. Deal-specific legal costs, like loan document review or title work, are recoverable transaction costs, while your firm's own retainer or employment-related legal spend is overhead. Blending the two makes deal-level cost reporting inaccurate.

What should we track when a deal falls through?

Beyond the dollar loss, track which deal types, borrower profiles, or lender relationships tend to fall apart most often relative to fees earned. That pattern is more useful for future underwriting decisions than the raw write-off total alone.

About the numbers

This guide doesn't quote a sourced benchmark. Figures in it are estimates or general guidance, so check them against your own numbers.

Related Guides